1919-S Walking Liberty Half Dollar For Grading Opinions.

Agree with fortcollins' breakdown.

FC may be correct that the example was photo adjusted to give it an original appearance. I am leaning toward the cleaning being a light dip before or after seller's photo.

I appreciate that FC. It's not easy finding a raw coin at the right price. Especially on ebay. A fairly priced coin is seldom a safe bet. This seller is rated 100% with zero negative reviews. Makes you wonder. Full refund is the only way I take my chances. Now I know why the price was to good to be true.
Nearly half of my set is NGC & PCGS graded examples liberated from their plastic prison that I find reasonably priced at Greysheet CPG.
Thanks again for your feedback.

Cleaned without a doubt

Many coin collectors, particularly those who are new to the hobby, underestimate the importance of learning how to identify the various forms of coin cleaning and surface alteration. Understanding the telltale signs of cleaning, recognizing the difference between natural wear and artificial damage, and knowing how these issues affect a coin's appearance, grade, and market value are essential skills when purchasing raw (uncertified) coins.

Another important consideration is that photographs do not always accurately represent a coin's true appearance. Lighting, camera angles, exposure, image editing, and reflections can either conceal imperfections or make a coin appear more attractive than it is in hand. Hairlines from cleaning, unnatural luster, discoloration, and surface damage may be difficult to detect in photographs, while certain lighting conditions can exaggerate or minimize these characteristics. Never assume that a coin looks in person exactly as it appears in an auction listing. Whenever possible, examine the coin under proper lighting, request additional photographs taken from different angles, and review the seller's return policy before bidding.

As someone who approaches coin collecting from a grading perspective, it's frustrating to see bidders pay premium prices for coins that show clear signs of cleaning, damage, or other impairments that can substantially diminish their value. A coin may look appealing at first glance, but its surfaces can tell a very different story upon closer examination. Cleaning or damage may also result in a Details grade rather than a straight numerical grade from a third-party grading service.

Unfortunately, there is only so much we can do beyond educating fellow collectors and helping them recognize what to look for. Study certified examples of cleaned and damaged coins, learn to recognize changes in luster and surface texture, and take the time to evaluate a coin before placing a bid. Most importantly, never let the excitement of an auction override sound judgment.

When buying raw coins, knowledge is your best protection. Learn to recognize what you're buying, understand what the coin is actually worth, and remember that an attractive photograph is no guarantee of an attractive coin in hand.