Toning On Silver Eagles

My american silver eagles all changed a little with their color. Any coin I believe will tone if they not inside of an air-tite holder.

I believe it is a function of environment and storage. Keep them (or any coins) in a dry, cool environment and there's a great chance they'll tone very little if at all. I have some bullion ASE's in my collection from back in the 80's and 90's that look brand new (only in my possession for the past couple years), and all the ones I have in OGP that I bought directly from the mint since the mid-90's are pristine still.

I live in a relatively dry climate and I keep my silver in a safe with a dehumidification system that consists of a wire basket full of those little desiccant packs you get in shoe and electronics boxes. So that certainly doesn't hurt.

That said, I've seen some gorgeous toning on ASE's and I love it. I'm a little biased anyway towards this particular coin, so in my opinion, a little toning here and there makes for an interesting set with more eye appeal, unless you are going for an absolutely pristine set.

I have a 1986 ASE (slabbed of course) in my 7070 and it does not show any toning.

I agree with the previous postings...it's about the environment in which the coins are kept.

OGP is small boxes, so I don't know that anyone does anything store those.

As the other have said, it really depends on how they are stored. Also, since they are pure silver vs 90% for things like Morgans, they tend to react more. It takes less exposure to say sulfur gas to cause toning on an ASE than it would your Peace dollars. I have an 86 that is solid light purple on the obverse and blaze on the reverse.I have no clue what caused it, but it is gorgeous. So I am one of the people that has absolutely no problem with toning.

if you don't have your coins encapsulated probably you will get some toning with the years, if you touch your coins with your fingers you will have toning from the oil of your skin too... some times encapsulated coins get toning too for different temperatures... that's what I seen in some of my coins...

foxwoods... Oh my!

My 1986 has a very light brown toning starting along the right side of the obverse.

My 1998 that I picked up from a coworker before he moved last fall has some insane blue-green toning that changes quickly rather than blending into the other colors of brown and black.

My overstruck Peace dollar pocket piece had started to tone after a year to a golden brown color but in the last 2 or 3 months has evolved into a deep purple hue around some the edge lettering (it is hard to capture the coloring and take a good picture of a once proof coin)

Looks real to me..typical look an ASE gets from sitting out in the open (nice clean reverse).I have a few just like that (and some silver spoons with the same tarnish err..toning

I think it looks cool