Pawn Stars Peace Dollar - A Different Perspective

First of all how is this a " different perspective " you are just hating on them like everyone did in the other thread on this subject.

Secondly "show of hands" who here has never over paid for a coin they really wanted ? Or bought a coin based on a RedBook, NGC or PCGS price guide price, because they really wanted the coin? What no hands ? I know mine isn't up.

These guys are not historians,numismatists,art experts, memorabilia experts, they are not even smart. They rely on their little panel of local " experts ". Obviously his local coin expert was wrong on this one, big deal. Because it was a punt load of money ? Tell that to the guy who paid $100,000 for the first Gold Kennedy, or the guy who paid $80,000 for the PF70 1995w ASE, or the guy who paid $28,000 for the MS70 2008/reverse of 2007 ASE. Big deal he has got a punt load of money to waste.

Finally, they weren't " busted " for anything, the consignment director of Heritage Auctions authenticated and assigned an auction value to that sports memorabilia. So on his authentication, they auctioned it off, it was only after the fact that all these other " authenticators " came out of the wood work for their " 15 minutes "

It is because everyone revels in the mistakes of successful people ?

I don't think the sky is going to fall on them. Their coin is a headliner at one of the two or three most important auctions of the year, and there's pent-up frustration on the part of the underbidders from the last two.

The most serious money in numismatics - the top of the economic food chain folks who are also lifelong dedicated collectors - overwhelmingly get into Silver Dollars even if shared with some other specialty. These folks will be in person, or represented, at FUN and that's the first time we'll hear them speak about this coin.

I think the game's afoot, all right, but I'm not sure it's the game being discussed.

Look at it this way: how tempting a target would that pawn shop be for a TV news fraud crew?

Edit to clarify: It's my opinion that everything you watched on TV was scripted to maximize this coin's value at FUN.

Second edit: I should also add that I think it's brilliant and I wish I'd thought of it myself.

The "coin expert" that he called in was the (head?) of NGC Ancients. I found it kind of funny that they would get a guy from the company that graded/authenticated the coin, but from the WRONG department.

Ok , I didn't read it that way, it seemed like another, 3rd or 4th, "hate on pawn stars" thread. In that case, I totally agree with you jimbucks. I am a very firm believer in " there is no such thing as a coincidence "

And their is no coincidence here. NGC Rep. authenticates a coin,Pawn Stars buys a coin, Pawn Stars hired by NGC to appear at FUN, Pawn Stars auctions said NGC certified coin at Fun.

Just like Vince McMahon wrote it.

This just came to mind. I was told HA sends all coins to CAC prior to auction. Since this coin does not have a bean (in the images I have seen), is it correct to assume CAC "rejected" it? Related question, if HA is asked whether to their knowledge a coin was submitted to CAC are they obligated to answer? If I were to bid on any high priced coin without a bean, I would really want to know such a disposition as part of due diligence.

denco7

A "punt load"?

New term for me

Fertilizer hasn't changed much in hundreds of years, just sayin' -

The entire show is scripted.