1948 Dollar "Full Repunched Date"

SPP, I wasn't ready to go that far, but the rim does have an odd line all the way around, in both obv and rev photos.

Looks like a counterfeit to me as well.

Thanks for editing DBM. I think when people say "counterfeit" they need to say why. Seller seems reputable. One of their other listings, 1938 dollar, has the same mushy appearance and is ICCS, so some of this may be just the photos.

very obvious fake

Seller says

I'm kind of sorry too - I originally thought this might be an interesting variety discussion instead.

obvious fake, hard to tell from the pics but it looks like the obverse initials are HD.

The counterfeits are getting better. I recently had someone bring in some Carson city Morgans that were very close to weight and looked great and were non magnetic. The slide magnet test proved no silver content as they were indeed fake. I believe this version of the 48 is significantly lighter at around 19 grams so I'm a bit surprised that it wasn't caught. That's enough difference to feel in hand even without looking at detail. Anyone can be fooled, more than the average amount of due diligence should be done when buying coins at that price. People who sell these depend on you having stars and dollar signs of profit in your eyes. The price it just expensive enough so it looks legit but cheap enough to look like a deal.