I think you hit the jackpot on your $5. That is LC-60E4 which is marked as "very rare" in my older token book (7th edition Charlton). Despite the overall look of the token, I'd say it looks better than the example in the book and would give it an AU. You can only see by the slight difference in colour on the eyebrow, several leaves, and on the ends of the flaps that there is any wear. On the reverse, the wear shows a little on the torso, breasts, face and a few spot on the top of the harp.