Really? I like this one for the toning, but I really like toned coins to a fault at times. I was looking at an MS-63 non-toned but decided against it since the few MS Seated Liberty quarters I picked up were toned. But, the 1884 non-toned one I'm looking at I'll pick up regardless just because of the low mintage. It will stick out for not sticking out so to say when viewed all together.