If I see this right, the first coin has an area raised on the reverse with an area just opposite on the obverse that is lower than the rest of the rim. This does appear to be a rim Cud on the reverse. The proof is the area on the obverse rim just opposite the Cud. Because of the missing area on the reverse die the corresponding area on the observe does not strike up as well. The only thing bothering me is the area on the obverse. I wouldn't expect the edges of it to be so sharp. I would expect the lower area to gradiually flow up to the rest of the rim. I wouldn't expect the abrubt lines. See what some of the other members say or maybe show some more pics of the edge and the obverse side.
The E just looks like it was struck through a small amount of grease. This is very common and carries no premium.
The E just looks like it was struck through a small amount of grease. This is very common and carries no premium.























