OK..I will take a shot at it...
1864 - VF20 - Maybe cleaned ? I guess you paid apx $25.00Obverse:
Rather worn on right side denticals
Arrow tips and leaf tips weak
Complete motto is visable but the words IN and WE is weak
Reverse:
I think I see a die crack above STATES
I think I see a die crack under AMERICA
1865 - EF40 - Nice color - I guess you paid apx $45.00Obverse:
Rather worn on lower left side denticals
Arrow tips and leaf tips weak
Complete motto is visable but the word WE shows trace of wear
1866 - AU50 - Nice color - I guess you paid apx $60.00Obverse:
Arrow tips and leaf tips show traces of wear
Complete motto is visable and the word WE is Bold
Reverse:
Maybe see small die crack above AMERICA
1868 - F12 - Color seems odd - I guess you paid apx $20.00Obverse:
Arrow tips and leaf tips show wear
Complete motto is visable but the word WE is weak
Reverse:
Maybe see small die crack between STATES and OF
1870 - F12 - Nice color - I guess you paid apx $38.00Obverse:
Arrow tips and leaf tips show wear
Complete motto is visable but the words IN and WE is weak
Reverse:
Hard to tell but maybe die crack in STATES
Some sort of string or grey hair on UNITED
1871 - VF20 - Maybe cleaned ? - I guess you paid apx $50.00Obverse:
Arrow tips and leaf tips show wear
Complete motto is visable but the word WE shows wear
Reverse:
Something going on with the N in UNITED
As you know, I am a beginner at this series and I am sure I missed a lot or seen some things that were not

Let me know how I did.
Out of the lot I like the 1866 the best

They are all beautiful coins....
