Profit Shares To Spend - What Should I Pick?

I have some profit shares on 2 accounts I need to spend. I'm looking for the best value. Below are my choices, I looked up the book value of each coin as well. I have 2,204 shares and 2,509 shares on each account. I want to spend them all. What should I pick on each account? Thanks.


Indian Head Pennies

1908 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze Average Circulated - 1,500 - $1.00

1907 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Fine - 1,900 - $2.00

1906 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Very Good - 1,800 - $7.00

1905 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,500 - $1.00

1904 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Good - 1,700 - $2.00

1903 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,500 - $1.00

1902 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,500 - $1.00

1901 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Good - 1,700 - $2.00

1900 Indian Head cent, Variety 3, Bronze - Average Circulated - 1,600 - $1.00


Lincoln Head

1935 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 - $0.05

1937 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 - $0.05

1939 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 - $0.05

1940 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 200 - $0.03

1944-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 900 - $0.61

1945 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 100 - $0.03

1945-S Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 2,200 - $0.76

1946 Lincoln Head Cent - Very Good - 200 - $0.05

1946-S Lincoln Head Cent - Very Good - 200 - $0.07

1948 Lincoln Head Cent - Very Good - 200 - $0.05

1949 Lincoln Head Cent - Average Circulated - 100 - $0.03

1954-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 500 - $0.26

1955 Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 600 - $0.23

1955-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 500 - $0.18

1955-S Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 700 - $0.26

1956 Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 400 - $0.12

1956-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 300 - $0.12

1958 Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 300 - $0.10

1958-D Lincoln Head Cent - Uncirculated-60 - 300 - $0.10


Liberty Head

1912 Liberty Head Nickel - Very Good - 2,200 - $3.20

1908 Liberty Head Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,700 - $1.46

1907 Liberty Head Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,700 - $1.46

1905 Liberty Head Nickel - Average Circulated - 1,700 - $1.46


Buffalo nickels

1937-D Buffalo nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 - $0.46

1936-S Buffalo nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 - $0.46

1936 Buffalo nickel - Very Fine - 1,400 - $1.95

1935 Buffalo nickel - Fine - 1,200 - $1.04

1930 Buffalo nickel - Average Circulated - 1,100 - $0.46

1929 Buffalo nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 - $0.46

1927 Buffalo nickel - Average Circulated - 1,000 - $0.46