I think the only premiums people are paying for common circulated coins is for melt value. This translates 2-3 cents for solid copper cents (pre-1997) and about 6-7 cents for solid nickel 5 cent coins (pre-1982). The exception to the rule is varieties and rarities.
Being retired from circulation does not always generate a premium. Just look at circulated Canadian silver coins. Almost 80 to 90% have been reclaimed / melted and most survivors still only fetch melt value. You have to back to the 1940s for dollar coins and pre-George VI era for all other circulated silver coins to see values well above melt .
Edited by 1945V
12/09/2013 06:40 am