Philadelphian, thanks for your suggestions, here is what I have found out:
S-123, the obverse date positions don't match my coin. Specifically the bottom of the 7 and the bottom of the first one, they should be closer with the 7 angling closer towards the bottom of the one. I don't think its S-123
S-131, the 'RT' in LIBERTY on the obverse is too far forward (to the right) of Liberty's hair in my coin, and my coin is missing the
Cud typically found on the obverse to the left of Liberty.
S-132, same as with S-131 with the 'RT' in LIBERTY. Additionally the 17 in the date have bases that are at the same level whereas in my coin the base of the 7 is noticeably lower than the base of the 1. Also the 9 in my coin the base is closer to the 7 than in S-132.
S-139, the date spacing is off, 'RT' is angled differently.
S-140, the 'RT' in LIBERTY on the obverse is too far forward (to the right) of Liberty's hair in my coin for it to be S-140. Date spacing is off as well.
S-133, I think this might actually be it. The 'R' in LIBERTY on the S-125 should be about touching Liberty's hair, in my coin it is spaced more like what is seen in S-133. The date placement of my coin appears to match S-133. Same die clashing in S-133 under Liberty's chin also present in my coin.
Thank you Philadelphian for pointing me in the right direction! Looks like S-133 is the likely variety. Anybody care to take a stab at confirming?
