2005-D Bison Nickel Rolls

The problem with any error coins is they are usually priced on popularity. Since no one really knows how many of any type of error is in existence, it just becomes something of popularity. For example look at that famous 1955 Lincoln Doubled Die. Actually there were many Doubles throughout the entire series but all you ever hear people talk about is the 22 plain, 55 Doubled Die. Same with the Buffalo nickels. It's that 3 legger that gets all the fame.
Yes, you may find some error coins in that mess and possibly could sell them on ebay. But I wonder if it's at all worth what you may end up with. Yet nothing to loose.

I have been buying 2005 nickel rolls because the obverse is a 1-year only design. I do like the Buffalo reverse over the Ocean View reverse.

It depends on the roll. I'll pay face for bank or generic rolls and will pay a small premium for a mint roll.

I found two rolls of the d ones last month at face. I ended up keeping them since bison are my favorite animal. Now I have a herd of 80 of them. Wish I could get that large or a herd of Buffalo nickels for $4. :)

I keep two rolls from roll hunting but I love Buffalo nickel and them using a new bison design on the nickel made me happy. If only they would do more turkeys

I have two mint sewn bags that I bought from the mint when they came out. I agree with what others said, any errors aren't going to bring much.

Considering something like 10% of the entire mintage was sold directly to the collector market (Not including the coins they scarfed up from the banks) I don't see these ever being worth a significant premium.