2005 Error Dime?

Post mint damage. If it were a broadstrike, there would be metal flow lines going into rim areas. The rim area of your coin was flattened under pressure. I can't see from the pictures but there is probablt evidence of reeding on the outside of your coin, which would be another reason why the rims were flattened unless the reeding was removed as part of the deception.

ok thanks for the quick response!

It does have reeding on the outside, but don't all dimes have reeding?

I have an old nickel at home I am curious about as well, I will post a photo later today, it has sever pitting on both sides, which I've read can be caused by oil getting onto the coin before striking? aside from getting acid splashed onto it, I cant picture anything else that would cause such pitting..

Do error coins lose their value when they have been circulated?

The reeding is formed when the coin is struck. The edge is forced into the reeded collar from the strike pressure. Therefore, your coin was originally struck normal with the reeding in place, then the rim area of your coin was flattened outside of the mint. The only way reeding would still be present would be if your coin was struck again without the collar in place. Your coin doesn't fit that scenario.