I agree with Ed. I don't really see any red flags. I see an honest VF-20 with some micro porosity. Has it been cleaned and retoned? Yes, they've all been cleaned and retoned. Just because it's dark doesn't mean anything. After 25 years of collecting large cents I've seen just about every color, surface, and type of damage that can happen to a 170 year old piece of copper. Yeah this coin is not the nice chocolate brown that copper collectors like to see but don't discount the poor girl, she's been around the block a few times. No need to keep it separate either.
Edited by Celticsoul
02/10/2015 07:38 am