Tunnioc,
compare this example to my comment on your 1907-O.
https://goccf.com/t/215937The LIBERTY is as sharp BUT the forehead hair and the ear curl are very weak.
So are the lower head feathers which should also be compared.
The 07-O has better feathers.
This is a typically weak New Orleans example which makes (barely) an XF-40 market grade.
(I would not buy it as such.)
If the two were dimes instead of halves I would pass on this example and pay over bid for the 07-O.
Value: Grey Sheet March 2015 (They do not use numeric grades so I assume VF-20 and XF-40)
VF Bid 150 Ask 165
XF Bid 350 Ask 385