Your coin is unquestionably a fake. The surface is all wrong. It was de-plated via reverse electrolysis. Jason Cuvelier wrote an excellent article on this for the Jan/Feb CONECA ErrorScope. He shows side by side comparisons of genuine, reverse electrolysis and acid stripped close ups. This is a perfect match for the reverse electrolysis fakes.
It is rare for a genuine unplated cent to be struck with a blemish-free brilliant finish. The vast majority that are fully brilliant are zinc plated fakes. In fact I've never seen a genuine unplated zinc come from of a reliable source (straight out of a counting room wrapping new coin), that was 100% fully brilliant. Not one! I have seen many fakes that are zinc plated, acid stripped and de-plated via reverse electrolysis.
The finish you see on the coin below is typical for a genuine piece. Note that both the genuine and fakes can have specs of copper in the surface.
Coin from the Ken Potter Collection.
Edited by koinpro
04/22/2015 5:37 pm