This looks similar to medals I have won in the past. It is mostlikely a stock catalog design that you would order at a trophy shop.
If you have every watched American Pickers or the show with the two old cowboys in Canada you will notice that they spend a lot of time getting the story of things. This is a good example of why they do it.
Items with no intrinsic value can be far more valuable if you know that this is a medal from the 1950 fall turkey shoot at Quakerville Gun and Rod Club that was won by a twelve year old girl named Maddie who outshot all the men in the single shot rifle competition to bring home a 20 pound turkey.