Think I'm Too Dumb To Submit To PCGS. Help!

Yes, they require them to be on separate forms, so you'll have to pay separate handling fees.

I believe you can send it to them in the same package, but I'm not sure. You would have to contact them to verify.

For return shipping, sometimes they can combine it. It depends which departments your coins go to. For example, I had a group of classics I was submitting at a show for them to send back to their office but also had 1 modern I wanted graded. I asked if they could be returned together, saving the separate shipping costs but they said no, bc they go to different departments, different places. You may have to contact them to talk specifics about where your coins could be returned together.

Yep, a separate form (with it's own handling fee & return shipping fee) for each type of submission. It doesn't pay to grade one coin or one crossover. Wait until you have a few unless they are big dollar rarities or you need immediate results for some reason.

You can ship them all to PCGS in one box if that's any consolation.

If you really want them submitted soon, maybe you can find a PCGS dealer to submit them for you. http://www.PCGS.com/dealers/

Some of them submit often, so it would be easy for them to add yours on. They'll probably just charge the grading fees plus a little for shipping (to and from PCGS), which is less than you by yourself because they're sending other coins too.