Fair Price For Huguenot Commemorative XF40

Based on recent ebay activity, you could likely find one for less than $60. One listed as being in XF condition recently sold for $35 (including the $3 shipping).

You mention the coin is graded by a TPG service. If it was not graded by PCGS, NGC, ANACS or ICG, the grade assigned might not be accurate and therefore of little value when determining the coin's market price. Such a case would definitely be one of "buy the coin, not the holder."

I agree with Biedercoins that the look of the coin in hand is a determining factor.

We had one around that grade at the LCS last year that I recall went for about $60 - I remember because I bid on it!