So I took back all of the pennies I searched yesterday and this time got an entire box at the same bank I got them from yesterday. I figured that since I got and Indian Head there once, I may as well try again.
No such luck this time, though I did manage to pull 15 wheats and 7 Canadian Pennies.
Wheats are:
1 - 1942
2 - 1944
1 - 1946
1 - 1947S (again, one I needed for my folder)
1 - 1948
1 - 1950
1 - 1951D
1 - 1955
2 - 1956
1 - 1956D
2 - 1957D
1 - 1958
Obviously not as exciting as finding the Indian Head, but still, the kids and I had a good time rooting through them.
I also managed to yank out 20 1968 pennies, as I saw there was this guy who collects them. Once I get to 50 I'll ship them off to him, I guess.