You CAN NOT take the 2011 Charlton as the bible on varieties. The 5 of us put together popular or moderately discussed Vicky varieties from website forums, as well as items we each had found. We listed just the "types" of varieties that you could expect to find when looking for Vicky anomalies. We also decided to include at least one example for every date in the Vicky series. We were restricted to 80 only and had a list of way over 100 that we could list before Charlton put the 80 limit on us. For 1858-1881 (the ones that most of us had done the most study on) we included those that had large offsets or were very interesting. The 2011 Charlton just shows EXAMPLES of what can be found. It is not a laundry list of what is available. Even not going into die-tracking like the Haxby site, there are probable way over 200 Vicky varieties that doesn't evolve into nitpicking. The study was done just to show what a person COULD find. For 1886, the final digit WAS handpunched, as are many Vicky dates. As such, you will find any number of dates that have the final digit "repunched". It's not really repunched ... it's a floor worker trying to take a handpunch and make it hit in the same place for 2 or more whacks to complete the die. All of the info in the 2011 Charlton was completed by us prior to June 2010, so that it could be put in the 2011 edition... anything discovered or discussed after that on CCRS or other sites won't be in there.