Coin Values Of Uncirculated Coins

As far as I know, the only thing that would determine the value of your coin is its condition, or grade. Anything MS-67 and above would be quite valuable it seems, but that would need to be determined by a credible TPG for someone to pay big bucks. Anything MS-65 and below is not worth getting graded.

I'm not a very good grader, but I don't think those pics would allow anyone here to properly grade it. It needs to be out of the plastic and pics need to be straight on, in focus and well-lit.



This page may help:

https://www.ikegroup.info/?page_id=32

Nicke: I share a lot of your confusion. Nevertheless,
the numismatic market is what it is.

As an individual, I am not attracted to modern coins (after about 1960) with MS-65 or above grades due to excessive pricing. Also, I would much prefer a MS-65 Ike to a MS-70 Ike, due to the lower price.
To me, an otherwise common coin in MS-70 is not a rare coin. Population grading numbers say differently.
I am much more interested in the numismatics of a coin than I am in it's condition.

Mints these days are very capable of producing MS-70 coins on a consistent basis. It then becomes a matter for the owner to keep them in that condition.
99% of the production of the 2009 proof Ultra High Relief Double Eagle is either PF-69 or PF-70, and I and would not be bothered in the least which grade I would own, because sure as eggs, I wouldn't be able to tell the difference.
I will let others be fanatical about that.

I never bother with on screen grading of coins that could be in the MS-65 to MS-70 range, and I defy anybody else to be able to do so accurately and consistently.

@Sel Couldn't agree more. Condition geeks can have their sets of flawless State Quarters. I'd much rather have a beat up coin that's rare in any grade than one that's only rare because it's immaculate.