Walking Liberty Semi-Key Grading!

Here's a stab at the grades/values:

1916-D: AG-3....$20

1917-D: AG-3....$15

1917-S: G-4.....$20

1919-S: AG-3....$15

1923-S: VG-8....$10

If you bought these for melt, you did very well. The '23-S is the only one of the bunch that should go as 90% junk silver.

The 1916-17s are worth a lot more than melt even in AG condition. Their mintmarks look a little too strong relative to the rest of the coin but you're probably okay there.

Melt?

Nice finds.