Any Thoughts On ICG ?

They tend to be a bit "optimistic" on the high end grades of modern coins but their grading of classics is pretty solid. Unfortunately, their overall reputation suffers from the glut of modern 69s and 70s.

Hi, I have used ICG for British and Commonwealth coins. I have used NGC and PCGS. I find the NGC pricing structure to be overinflated and I have found the grading variable. I have found PCGS consistent buy not very helpful and pricey if before 1955. I seek quality protection for my rare coins and an honest grade. ICG has been right on the mark for the many world (UK, South African, New Zealand, Australia, Indian ...) coins I have sent to be graded. Their grading has been consistent and accurate. I like their level of professionalism and understatement. At 12 dollars per coin for a value grade (under 500 dollars in pecuniary worth), it represents excellent value for money. As a secondary matter, I appreciate the ability to customise the label with my own collection signature since my coins are part of an extensive and respected series. Politics and dealer bias aside, I find ICG well worth it as an investment in the security and pedigree of my coins. --CP--