Quote:
So if you have a proof-like MS68-69 for them to grade could they not think that it was a proof and grade it as such?
Proof coins and business strikes are produced with two completely different minting processes. Modern proofs will be struck at least twice with specially prepared dies. Franklin proofs are typically brilliant so they will have highly reflective surfaces. Since they are struck multiple times, the rims are squared and all details are strong- full bell lines are to be expected on Franklin proofs. Proof Franklins will typically grade high unless they have been mishandled. The primary marks will be hairlines.
Mint State business strikes will generally have overall weaker detail than proofs and the surfaces will not be brilliant. Fields will be lustrous from die flow lines and the primary marks will be bagmarks. It is very uncommon for a business strike to grade over MS65 and proof-like Franklins are exceedingly rare so it would be virtually impossible to have an MS68-69 PL Franklin.