Jeff, I certainly hope that you did not clean it because of my harsh remark about it. I didn't mean the toning was ugly, (although it actually was). What I was referring to were those white spots (that remain). 'Looks like' hard water spots, but I have heard about 'milky spots' on newer silver coins, though I thought that these were possibly the effects of some brands of slabs. I am sure that someone here will know the nomenclature of the spotting, and if there is a possible remedy.