Hi "Ugly",
I think that we are generally in agreement that these items are OK if presented in the correct manner (i.e. not as coins). It is just that I have seen so many on
ebay which are not properly marked that I have gone against them so strongly. Then there are mints such as Pobjoy who create "coins" for a bit of uninhabited rock in the ocean. I think that you know what I mean by that. I certainly don't have any objections to you collecting them as "artwork".
In other forums, there are some who think that Edward VIII British coins really exist and my input was really to put an end to that supposition. That is why I think that they should by relegated to a non-coin section.
Please accept my best wishes.
Bill.