| Author |
Replies: 49 / Views: 5,651 |
|
|
|
Valued Member
United States
364 Posts |
Bigfredd gave sage advice - buy what you like. For bullion I like Maple Leafs and ASE's. Check out Goldmart too. They sell Maple Leafs for 2.19 over spot and ASE for a bit more over spot. Here are 20 Maple Leafs in my cart for $648 (silver is up tonight). Good luck. http://www.goldmart.com/checkout/cart/
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
9104 Posts |
Quote: Ok now explain to me how a milk spot hurts the value of a BULLION coin? It doesn't not one bit. It doesn't hurt the bullion value, but some "bullion" coins become collectable.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
4008 Posts |
Quote: It's really nice to have people take the time to respond and help you learn and be informed. Indeed it is... and advice like this is all the more valuable because the people in here are not trying to sell you anything... unless you are in the buy-sell area, of course. 
|
|
New Member
United States
38 Posts |
Me personally, I started in bars. I grew tired of them and started purchasing ASE and CML, simply because they are more interesting to me. Buy what ever you like the most!
|
|
Valued Member
United States
410 Posts |
If you are trying to decide between Canadian Maples and Silver Eagles I would favor the Maples. The Maple is a $5 face coin while the Silver Eagle is a $1 coin.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
1502 Posts |
the face value don't really matter because banks and stores have the right to refuse to accept NCLT (non-circulating legal tender). Milky spots are more common on the maples than eagles but then if you're not re-selling the maples individually to private collectors then the white spots matters very little. Also, the trade off for no milk spots on the eagles is that small dings and imperfect strikes show up much more apparent on the eagle's BU/sandy finish.
Just go with your gut (we all know your appetite will extend much further than maples and eagles anyways.)
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Japan
666 Posts |
the face value don't really matter because banks and stores have the right to refuse to accept NCLT (non-circulating legal tender)>>>>
where does this right come from?
|
|
Valued Member
United States
122 Posts |
Please tell me if I understand this correctly. I wish to speculate in silver bullion at this time. PART 1: I can buy some well circulated Morgan silver dollars of common dates for a minimal premium. Since they are 90% silver and widely accepted, they should vary in price roughly along with the spot price of silver. If I buy these Morgans on ebay, the seller is paying around 11%-12% for commissions and Pay-Pal fees, so he wants to ask a 12% premium at least. But if it is an auction with no reserve, he cannot control the final price. I also have to pay shipping. If I purchase them from a local PM shop or at coin show, those fees would not exist, but the seller will still charge what the traffic will bear. Therefore, I should be aware of what these basic Morgans are selling for on ebay before I go to the dealer or to a coin show and make sure I negotiate a reasonable price. PART 2: If I hold the Morgans for 3-4 years and silver has doubled and I then sell them on ebay, I have to pay around 12% selling cost on the new DOUBLED price. That is 24% of what they cost me. Where should I sell them at that time? To a local PM dealer? At the local coin club bourse prior to the meetings? Advertise on Craigslist? Hawk them to dealers at the next coin show? Hmmm. I wonder. What is best? If dealing solely through ebay, the rate of return in this case for a four-year hold may only be around 13% per annum for an asset that had doubled in value. Perhaps that is reasonable. I once bought a piece of land for $7000 and sold it after 13 years for $21,000. Sounds great, no? But the annual real estate tax and the cap gains tax just about ate up the profit. My rate of return was very low. PART3: What about buying silver bars? Can I get a decent deal at the local PM dealer? I think bars are larger and can't be moved as readily as silver dollars. PART 4: What about ASE's? Don't these have a numismatic value in addition to the price of silver? How do they fit in for the PM speculator? PART 5: What about these US Mint issues of these 5-oz silver bars? Are they better or worse than any of the above investments? I would appreciate comments from anyone with experience in this area. I just sold an asset and received the cash so I'm ready to deal. I want to dollar-cost average into silver over the next six to eight months. Thank you.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
4008 Posts |
Big-Byte: I don't have answers to all of your questions but I will says a few things to which others on here can add their thoughts. Quote: Since they are 90% silver and widely accepted, they should vary in price roughly along with the spot price of silver. Yes, Morgans are nice coins and make good additions to almost any collectors' stash. Any number of Morgans are considered collector coins, though, and can be price WELL above the spot price of their silver content. The Carson City mint versions, for example. Also, their condition will affect their price. BU grade coins will sell for more money than cull grade coins. There are maybe 4-5 intermediate grades as well. There are also graded coins that have a specific quality rating on them that can sell for quite a lot more than their silver value. None of this is intended to discourage you from investing in Morgans but to help you become aware of the possibilities that they offer. As to ebay... some people do well at buying and selling there but I don't really care for it myself. I buy from APMEX, Provident Metals, and SilverTowne. All 3 of these are good places to do business and I have had good experiences with all of them. When I shop for silver, I most often do it based on price and availability. Shipping costs matter, so include them in with the prices of the coins you buy. I also have a couple of local coin / pawn shops where I buy coins from time to time. Most of the time, these are either ASEs or US 90% silver coins in various denominations. I have not tried to sell any silver locally but would try the same local shops where I buy to see what they would offer. After that, I would check with the on-line vendors to see what they would pay for what I was selling. Once we know what is offered we can make an informed choice as to where to sell our silver. Yes, you can buy bars as well as rounds and coins of various types. Bars usually come in various sizes, such as 1, 5, 10, 50, and 100 ounces each. There are also a few odd sizes, such as 2, 3, and 20 ounce bars. I prefer to buy bars that are wrapped in air-tight plastic so they stay nice looking for many years. Oxidation does not do much harm to the silver but it does detract from their appearance. A private collector might not pay as much for a bar that doesn't look nice. Businesses tend not to care about that as much but there are always exceptions. I also prefer bars that have the silver purity and weight stamped into the bar. A serial number is also nice in that it could be useful for identifying any bars recovered after a theft. For all of the above reasons, I prefer the SilverTowne 5 and 10 oz. bars although there are quite a few other bars available that are very nice too. ASEs are terrific for silver collectors. They are guaranteed as to weight and purity by the US Mint. They contain a solid ounce of 99.9% silver metal and have a great design. You can get them in tubes of 20 coins or in monster boxes of 25 tubes / 500 coins. They are widely recognized by anyone who buys and sells silver bullion. Yes, there is a $3-5 premium attached to each coin but this is part of the cost to manufacture, transport, store, and sell these coins. We might or might not be able to recover all or part of this premium when selling. I have not dealt with the US Mint so cannot comment on that.
|
|
Valued Member
United States
410 Posts |
Quote: the face value don't really matter because banks and stores have the right to refuse to accept NCLT (non-circulating legal tender) That would be news to me and completely contrary to the definition of the word. Legal Tender: (Noun) Currency in specified denominations that a creditor must by law accept in redemption of a debt.
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
9104 Posts |
Quote: If you are trying to decide between Canadian Maples and Silver Eagles I would favor the Maples. The Maple is a $5 face coin while the Silver Eagle is a $1 coin. Great, so if the silver market drops below $5, you can lose $4 more on ASE, but are protected with the CML. Then again, if you think silver may drop below $5,  are you buying it at $30?
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
2168 Posts |
I think when some talk of face value its kind of to say something that it could be spent for that value. I alsO think some think it has to do with possible confiscation. Somehow with the face it can not be included with bars etc. I could be wrong but it just is something I recall reading about. I don't care about the 'face' value. One of the most strange is the 25CENTS on the 5 oz silver coins!
|
|
Valued Member
United States
122 Posts |
Thanks a lot, Ed_B. I am going to shop those three stores that you mentioned. I am now better armed to understand the Morgans.
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
9104 Posts |
Quote: the face value don't really matter because banks and stores have the right to refuse to accept NCLT (non-circulating legal tender)>>>>
where does this right come from? "Legal Tender" only has to be accepted in payment of a debt. Purchases are not debts unless they're put on a monthly account. Some dealers took a few $100,000 in Canada Olympic coins to redeem when the silver price dropped to less than face (same as this scenario). They couldn't spend the, couldn't even deposit them so they could convert to USD. They eventually were allowed to spend them at face for other mint products at retail.
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
9104 Posts |
Fellow big- There are a number of factors that go into pricing at any given moment, and no guarantees for the future. For example, for awhile it was illegal to import krands, and they sold for $10-20 less than other ounce gold bullion coins, because people were afraid they were illegal to own. Today, they don't have that stigma, and folks who bought them during the scare days made an extra $10-20 per coin. Speaking of "circumstances". Most fractional gold sells for a premium, but the argument is that you'll get back the premium when you sell. Not always true: GOLD KRUGERRAND BID ASK
1 OZ 1671.50 1748.75
1/2 OZ 820.00 883.50
1/4 OZ 410.00 452.00
1/10 OZ 164.00 195.75 Note that the bid price is 31.50 per oz lower, but there is a premium for fractionals when buying.
|
| |
Replies: 49 / Views: 5,651 |