Why Would Somebody Report My Listings As Replica From CCF?

Thanks for clearing that up Sap




Hmm Swamper bob an Idiot, I doubt that very much

These people are simply trying to make ebay a safer place to buy coins and they have prevented many a shonky seller profiting from their dodgy sales.

OK they stopped your listings, Possibly to check and make sure that they were kosher.
You can now list them again

Jumping up and down, talking about suing and bagging people will get you absolutely nowhere at all.
ebay is a private business and nobody gets to "Vote" on how they run their business.
If you are unhappy with ebay then vote with your feet and take your business elsewhere, Nobody is "Forcing" you to use ebay.
Just saying

Yes, you probably would; but you would also see the reference to CCWG if someone clicked on the "Report Item" link on your listing, too, or if they reported your item in some other non-CCF-related fashion.

Here's how I understand ebay's counterfeit reporting system to work.

- The listing is reported - either by the CCF manual reporting link or one of the more automated reporting links elsewhere on ebay.
- An ebay Safety and Trust person examines the listing. If it's a clear-cut, open-and-shut-case policy breach, they presumably take action directly themselves. Likewise if it's clearly not a policy breach, then the report is ignored. The owner of the listed item never even knows somebody reported their item.
- If it is ambiguous, the Safety and Trust person forwards the item to the CCWG for their vote.
- CCWG members vote on whether it's a policy breach or not. It's this part I am uncertain of - what result of the voting causes an item to be pulled? Simple Majority? Absolute Majority? Two-Thirds Majority? Unanimous? Do you only need one "No" vote against it to cause an item to be pulled? Are the votes weighted in favour of certain experts who have proven to be better at that certain kind of counterfeit? You'll have to ask your new friend in Trust & Safety if they can inform you of this.
- Based on the CCWG vote, either the item is then pulled or the report is ignored.

You shouldn't be too hard on whoever reported it, or on the CCWG. ebay themselves have admitted their policy was sufficiently ambiguous and, as we saw earlier in the thread, Canadian law is likewise sufficiently ambiguous about this. It would indeed be nice to see if ebay really does clear up this ambiguity with some new or re-worded policies.

pawnS are you calling me a idiot?

no not him. Obviously I am upset about this but at the same time if some one called a professional cant differentiate a counterfeit/replica from the real thing just plated......
How would you feel in a situation like this? Knowing you are right and the person reporting you is not? How does the credibility of CCW look?

wow that is a very rude comment

Nobody here is having a heart attack but you.. You seem very concerned about what I want to do... FYI They are selling at $9.99 not $2 but thanks for your comments..

what is your point ? Obviously actions are actions the prices are up and down some got away for cheap but a majority were high.. Also I noticed ever since you joined this site you have been very disrespectful toward the members here and as I recall a moderator made a comment about it..
ssuperDdave


I totally agree with this moderator your posts have been disrespectful in some many ways.

SsuperDdave
I don't think I am over reacting. Reason being today after I listed my items maybe about 1 hour later ebay Again removed my items because they received yet another almost identical complaint only this time claiming they are counterfeit.. They have relisted them and now are investigating the source of these complaints. Also I did mention getting a lawyer involved because this is now the second time this has happened and although it might be a small amount of money it still is my money... And yes I have been wrong before but I don't think I am wrong now.