I can not comment directly on the quality of the older ANACS holders with DMPL coins as I have not purchased any.
I recently crossed all my ANACS holders (none DMPL) to PCGS, so the biggest issue that I see with ANACS is that it can be difficult to cross the coin to NGC or PCGS as NGC does not cross any ANACS coins and PCGS is currently very stick on crossing DMPL. The grading standards in recent years appear to be have tighten on DMPL coins from both PCGS and NGC.
I recently crossed all my ANACS holders (none DMPL) to PCGS, so the biggest issue that I see with ANACS is that it can be difficult to cross the coin to NGC or PCGS as NGC does not cross any ANACS coins and PCGS is currently very stick on crossing DMPL. The grading standards in recent years appear to be have tighten on DMPL coins from both PCGS and NGC.
























