|
This page may contain links that result in small commissions to keep this free site up and running.

Welcome Guest! Registering and/or logging in will remove the anchor (bottom) ads and the security checks. It's Free!
To participate in the forum you must log in or register. | Author |
Replies: 6 / Views: 1,145 |
|
|
Valued Member
Japan
294 Posts |
I'm sure anyone that studies the PD can see that there are two different types of the "Type 2 Low Relief" Peace dollar in 1922. I put pictures of what I call the Type 2A and Type 2B respectively down below. The Type 2A seems to have a much lower mintage, and I'm guessing is the one that came before the Type 2B, of which was used for the remainder of the series. Does anyone know the exact reason behind not recognizing these obvious differences? As a collector, the idea of not doing so only because "it would be bothersome" seems to undercut its interesting history, or why those changes may have occured.    
|
|
|
|
Valued Member
 Japan
294 Posts |
Also, would it be safe to assume that there were 1922 Type 2B proofs created, then melted down just like the 2A proofs and just haven't been discovered yet? I can't imagine the mint making a change to the dies and not testing it like they did the previous versions. And if one is found, I wonder if they'll have to recognize it as a type 2B proof, or something to that effect... A big part of the value behind the existing proofs isn't only because they're rare, but because they add further insight into how the Peace dollar was created (which is pretty fun to read about!) If anyone has some further knowledge/opinions on the topic I would love to hear it.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
4511 Posts |
I am not understanding what you are calling a type 2A and 2B. Can you explain the difference? There were a lot of different dies used on the 1922 date and therefor are many different VAMs. The same basic design was used on the obverse and reverse for the 1922 date. Van Allen called the obverse used on the 1922: II obverse and the reverse: B reverse.
|
|
Valued Member
 Japan
294 Posts |
From what I've heard, there were some back-and-forth alterations and help from George Morgan to make the dies more sustainable, much to Fransisci's chagrin. And I've read reports from the likes of Van Allen, Roger Burdette and others that oftentimes conflict with each others' speculations, so there doesn't seem to be any solid verdict on this transitional period, only speculation. But all I can say is what I see on the coin itself. The olive branch on the Type 2a is further away from the leg and appears as a stub, and the 2a lacks the stem-like incuse above the back talon of the right leg that every Type 2b has. It also lacks the third mountain top as show in these pictures:  
|
|
Valued Member
 Japan
294 Posts |
If you look up particular VAM photos they only appear in either Type 2a or Type 2b. They are never mixed. For example, every 1922 VAM 1A "Line in Tiara" has the qualities of what I'm calling the 2a, but every VAM 2B "Earring" will have the longer stem, third mountain top etc that match the 2b. The Type 2a doesn't appear near as much, which leads me to think that the change to a 2b design were made soon after the start of circulation.
|
|
Valued Member
 Japan
294 Posts |
If we say "it wasn't a design change, but that more of the stem and mountain top started appearing due to a change in how heavy the strike was", how are the devices on the 2a always so much more crisp and clear? Compare any equally graded Type 2a and 2b and the 2a will win the prize for precision every time. All the feathers look like they can be counted on even a 63-graded 2a, and the lines in Liberty's hair more pristine, but a 2b with that level of detail can't be found. If we say somehow that "a weaker strike was used for the 2b", why are there details appearing on the "weaker strike" that aren't on the stronger one? (olive branch incuse, third mountain top, etc)
It doesn't add up, unless I'm completely missing something.
You could also say "it was an issue with the mint" but both types can be found in all three mints, and only in 1922. A Type 2a can't be found in later years from what I've seen.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
4511 Posts |
That is some great information. You should reach out to Roger Burdette as he can be found on the NGC chat board with user name RWB. Roger should be able to answer your question on the reason behind not recognizing these obvious differences. Roger is as good as there is on gathering historical information that could answer the question when the differences took place.
|
| |
Replies: 6 / Views: 1,145 |
|
To participate in the forum you must log in or register.

- 1975 D Lincoln Cent 2 Lincoln's Reverse Memorial And Obverse
- 1974 San Marino 20 Lire, PCGS MS-67, San Marino, Lobster
- 1795 Liberty Cap Large Cent, PCGS AU-58+, S-76 Struck Over 1794 S-71, Jeff Garrett Discovery
- 2026 Declaration Of Independence Quarter With July 4th Privy Mark, PCGS MS-66
- 1978 Mexico - 10 Centavos W/Straight Clip
- 2019 P Nickel: WDDR-005
- 1994-P Nickel Overpolished Die?
- 2022 10c Double Clipping Error
- 1871 Victoria Sovereign, London
- Possibly Merovingian 8th Century
- Specie Payments Suspension And Gold Coin Circulation After 1861 In The Usa?
- Looking For Nic-A-Date Pro's And Con's
- 2021-P Nickel With Feeder Finger Damage.
- 2025 P Nickel With DDR.
- 2021 - P Lincoln Shield Cent With Uncentered Broadstrike, Stiff Collar, And Ffd (Coin #3 Of 3)
- 2005 - D Lincoln Memorial Center With Broadstrike (Coin #2 Of 3)
- 2000 - P Lincoln Memorial Cent Wide AM Gift
- 1999 - P Lincoln Memorial Cent With Broadstrike (Coin #1 Of 3)
- 1872-H Off-Centre Double Struck 25 Cent
- 2026 Trump Dollar Coin - Strikethrough Or Ding?
- 2026 W Enduring Liberty 09-11-01 Always Remember Privy Coins Possible Variety.
- How Far Back Can We Go? Ninth Edition!
- Definitive Test For Black Beauty Nickels
- How Many Countries Do You Have Coins From?
- 20 Questions! (Forum Game) 11/04/24
- 1975 D Lincoln Cent 2 Lincoln's Reverse Memorial And Obverse
- 1974 San Marino 20 Lire, PCGS MS-67, San Marino, Lobster
- Guess The Price - Season 96 - Round 4
- Coinstar Finds! (Including Bank Counters And Other Machines)
- How To Spike Interest In The Comic Art Series
- Explore Rare And Collectible Coins From Specialist Dealers On Ma-Shops.
- 1795 Liberty Cap Large Cent, PCGS AU-58+, S-76 Struck Over 1794 S-71, Jeff Garrett Discovery
- 2026 Declaration Of Independence Quarter With July 4th Privy Mark, PCGS MS-66
- Post Your United Kingdom (Great Britain) Coin Acquisitions.
- Purchased A Small Celtic Hoard
- Post Your Coins With Coats Of Arms, Shields, Crests, Crowns, Etc.
- Around The World With Coins - A Coin Geography Game
- Specie Payments Suspension And Gold Coin Circulation After 1861 In The Usa?
- New Coin Purchases, Slerk
- 1623 2 Thalers, Germany, Constance, D-5175, PCGS XF45
Disclaimer: While a tremendous amount of effort goes into ensuring the accuracy of the information contained in this site, Coin Community assumes no liability for errors. Copyright 2005 - 2026 Coin Community Family- all rights reserved worldwide. Use of any images or content on this website without prior written permission of Coin Community or the original lender is strictly prohibited.
Contact Us | Advertise Here | Privacy Policy / Terms of Use
|
| Coin Community Forum |
© 2005 - 2026 Coin Community Forums |
| It took 0.25 seconds to rattle this change. |
 |
|
| |
| |