| Author |
 Replies: 16 / Views: 6,092 |
Page 2 of 2
|
|
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
3077 Posts |
|
|
New Member
United States
5 Posts |
The design of this "commemorative" medal bothers me a lot. Why have they left off the name of our
country? And the Sept 11 date? And a clear reference to Freedom and the events of that day? I realize the
figure on the obverse is supposed to be Lady Liberty, but it looks more like an Olympic torch lighting
ceremony than a 9/11 tribute. Sure, most of us understand what this medal refers to. But what about a few
decades from now? There's nothing on this medal to identify what it really stands for.
The men, women, children and heroes of 9/11 deserve better than this. We all do.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
3077 Posts |
very good points Palidin and though I like the design I hadnt considered the issues that you have brought up
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
4778 Posts |
It's alright. Not a big fan of the reverse font though...
|
|
Valued Member
United States
223 Posts |
I ordered one of each today. As Jango said they are alright. I thought
they were a little to Politically Correct or maybe just to plain. I did
like the fact that $10 from each purchase went to the National September 11 Memorial & Museum.
Just my opinion.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
543 Posts |
I really want to order this set. A generous portion of the purchase price is going toward a great cause. I also wonder if purchasing both of these (West Point & Philadelphia) will pay off in the long run?
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
9104 Posts |
How to play it:
As a collector
If you like it and it's worth the price, buy it.
As a philanthropist
Send a check to the charity, you don't need a middleman, and you can take the deduction.
As an investment
By 2015, these will sell for melt, just like the music medals pre-1986.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
10284 Posts |
I still can't seem to accept anyone capitalizing on one of the saddest and definitely the most horrifying day in my lifetime.
The whole event has never settled with me yet and I don't need a coin to "Always Remember". I don't like it at all.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
12437 Posts |
Quote:
The design of this "commemorative" medal bothers me a lot. Why have they left off the name of our
country? And the Sept 11 date? And a clear reference to Freedom and the events of that day? I realize the
figure on the obverse is supposed to be Lady Liberty, but it looks more like an Olympic torch lighting
ceremony than a 9/11 tribute. Sure, most of us understand what this medal refers to. But what about a few
decades from now? There's nothing on this medal to identify what it really stands for.
The men, women, children and heroes of 9/11 deserve better than this. We all do.
 That is one of the best first posts I have seen in a long time, I also have issues with the vague allegory of the medal and believe that the true remembrance is lost on unrelated symbolism. I see the point of HONOR but HOPE? What are we hoping for, to not get attacked again? After the hijacking of that word by the current president, it simply does not belong on this medal and is meaningless to the discussion. This medal could have been so much more, even with some of the other lackluster designs but Timmy Tax Cheater Geithner had to further bollux it by choosing that reverse over the choice of the of the CCAC and CFA. Depicted below is the reverse that was chosen then overruled.  |
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1745 Posts |
Too politically correct. More of the same from the mint. I view this as a wasted opportunity.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
 United States
12843 Posts |
I'm very torn on buying these medals and agree with biggfredd (reasons for buying/not), The_Duke (wasted opportunity by the mint), biokemist (MUCH prefer the wording on the vetoed reverse). And paladin - I agree with your entire sentiment. They could have done so much more. But I'm still torn. When I saw the email I was pretty excited to cruise on over to the Mint site and spend yet more money ( ATB pucks are killing me!) because I thought the cause/donation was great and was hoping the medal would be appropriately breathtaking, but after seeing the design, I just don't know if I'm gonna do it. This may as well be a tribute to all the soldiers that have died in the 10 years that we've been at war since 9/11, not just the public servants and civilians that lost their lives on that horrific day. And that would be fine; quite obviously they deserve it just as much. But nothing like that is mentioned in the description. I guess I'm just confused/sad/unhappy/dissappointed by the design. :( Why not a simple design depicting the Twin Towers or perhaps the new Freedom Tower (or One World Trade Center, as it's officially known now). SOMETHING to actually remind us of what happened that tragic day as paladin suggests. And welcome, paladin! |
|
New Member
United States
1 Posts |
To CelticKnot or others,
The design does not directly show the Twin Towers and the Sept. 11. It looks very plain.
But if you see the front side, there are two white strips in the background. They are the Twin Towers.
The light is hold by the lady has a circle around it, and with the arm to hold it, they look like 9. Now the two white strips are 11 with fire.
This is just what I saw from it.
Thanks
|
|
New Member
United States
5 Posts |
I went ahead and purchased one of these in order to have it holdered by PCGS with the "First Strike" designation. The irony of the holder label will not go unnoticed.
|
|
Valued Member
United States
362 Posts |
My wife pointed something out to me on the one I just got. I knew there was something about the look of the reverse wording that did not look good to me. Then I showed it to my wife, she said the font choice is wrong, plus she did not like the cascading water in the reverse either but liked the eagle and the obverse. I think a simple engraving of the flag or of the eagle with the flag would have been great.
|
|
Valued Member
United States
193 Posts |
I for one, will not be buying this coin. To me the look of it is bad, bordering on hideous. The eagle looks like it is a computer generated image using a computer running windows 3.1 The font on the reverse doesn't look right and the image of Lady Liberty (if that is who that is supposed to be) just looks retarded.
All in all I think the coin design was rushed with more emphasis on just getting one out than getting it right.
Sorry but not for me.
|
|
Page 2 of 2
|
Replies: 16 / Views: 6,092 |
Page 2 of 2
|
First Page
Posted 06/14/2011 5:04 pm
