In an open auction I'd get between $45 and $60 for it. So you have a lot of power in this negotiation as the seller is top rated plus and you can get eBay to deduct your money back for any reason from his account and he can't do anything about it for 30 days if you don't like the coin for any reason. So if it was me, I'd offer $50, if he counters $65 or under take it, if he declines note in a message to him there is an equal or better example at VCOINS in Victor's shop for $80 and his is guaranteed for life where this seller even being top rated plus does not say that so your firm bottom price is $65. And if he still does not take it buy Victors. At least that is what I would do.