Your white metal,pewter, tin one according to HK is a R-7 which means they know of 11 to 20 examples when the listing was made. Also the hole isn't an issue. HK doesn't give values other than a spread . I don't know if the other condition issues with yours makes a difference. I think it would depend on how much somebody would want that piece. I don't do early American tokens. The price supplement for my edition of Hibbler& Kappen is from 2008 the number is HK1004 has a spread of $1500./2000USD. Whether that has gone up or gone down. I hope you didn't drop a lot of money hoping to turn a fast flip. since the market for the high end tokens does fluctuate with peoples taste.