Hmm...I'm not sure. Just remember a lot of the examples that we tend to see of 1925 Penny's are well worn Fine to Very Fine. In those examples you can't see the height of the coin which is what the speculation seems to be about. Have a look on the few 1925 pictures on their up & coming auction
http://www.downies.com/aca/Auction3...gue_052.html as they will allow you to see a better indication of the coin itself. The curveture of the base of the letters seems to be too much, especially on the right hand side of the obverse, because the strike looks weak towards the outer side of the rim (& top side of the letters).
Got me stumped.