| Author |
Replies: 25 / Views: 2,873 |
|
Valued Member
United States
162 Posts |
Looking through my wheaties some more for die clashes and I'm almost positive I finally found one. The name of the Die Clash is TDC-1c-1925S-01 and information about it can be found at: http://www.maddieclashes.com/TDC-1c-1925S-01.htmlAnyone know any more about these, no clue what the value would be. I couldn't find any recorded sales. Also, I'd like a 2nd opinion or 3 about whether this really is a Clashed Die Error. I highlighted some clashed spots that were a little harder to see. Didn't highlight the outline of Abe's shoulder/head that's on the reverse as it's quite obvious.    
|
|
|
|
Moderator
 United States
56855 Posts |
I don't think the reverse is considered a die clash it's referred to as "ghosting" or die wear https://goccf.com/t/80533John1 
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
162 Posts |
Everywhere I've read says Die Clashing is on the obverse and the reverse. Every example I've seen of Die Clashing has clashes on both sides, I've yet to see a die clash on just 1 side. I don't think it's physically possible to have a die clash on 1 side considering how they happen. A die clash is caused when a blank doesn't enter and the 2 sides of the dies strike each other and leave imprints of themselves on the other side. I've never heard of "ghosting", probably just an nontechnical term that someone used. Checkout http://www.maddieclashes.com
|
|
Moderator
 United States
56855 Posts |
Quote: I've yet to see a die clash on just 1 side. Dies get changed all the time and they usually only change one of the two dies. I am familiar with the web site. Neff and Diamond are members here. John1 
|
|
Rest in Peace
United States
1943 Posts |
Die clashes can be on one side. One of the dies can be replaced after a clash leaving the other die hanging or both dies can be removed, polished and then reinstalled but not together as a set.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
162 Posts |
True, they can change 1 side of the die but personally I haven't seen a single sided die clash variety yet, at least not with wheat cents. I wasn't concerned about that part of what he said though. The thing he said that concerned me is "I don't think the reverse is considered a die clash it's referred to as "ghosting" or die wear". Die clashes 100% of the time will occur on the reverse (and obverse), that is until they change the reverse die.... I went to the thread you linked and my coin is completely different than the one in that thread. The "ghosting" that guy is seeing is done by tilting the coin at an extreme angle so they light catches weird, I have handfuls of shiny pennies that do that. This isn't the case, this picture is from straight above and doesn't catch the "glare/ghosting". Not to mention there's several thing's that match up almost identical with the 1925-S Die Clash Variety and it's 6% tilt.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
162 Posts |
Plus, in that guys thread he has the coin upside-down and is looking at it the wrong way. The reflection of Abe's head on his coin is in the word "One" which is completely wrong. The image of Abe on that guy's coin would have to be flipped 180 degrees to be a die clash. Look at the overlay that I made above and you'll see what I'm saying. Abe's head needs to be under "United States of America" not in the word "One".. lol.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
162 Posts |
You might be confused because not many Wheat cent die clashes show as much of an outline of Abe's head/bust as the 1925-S. Most just show minor clashes of Abe's bust/head going from the "C" in "CENT" to the "I" of "UNITED" & another going from the "E" in "ONE" to the "N" in "CENT". Here's the pictures straight from MadDieClashes of the 1925-S 1C Clashed Die:   As you can see in this picture, the placement of the bust and head is identical to my coin. Abe's bust begins to the right and slightly above the left wheat ear. It continues to the bottom of the "C" in "CENT" where it starts it's curve to the head. It continues and crosses through the center of "N" in "UNITED" and then again through the center of "O" in "OF". My die clash actually looks more clear than the example, possibly mine was struck before the die was abbraded a ton. Mine has a clear "5" in the right wheat ear, and part of the "L" of "LIBERTY" in the rim. I can also see part of the "W" of "WE" in the bottom of the coin but it's hard to capture it clearly in an image. Also, to further justify that my coin IS a Die Clash, if you look at the points where the dies clash, my coins is abraded in all of the clashed places which is a definite warning sign that this was a Clashed Die.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
3640 Posts |
Have found over a dozen decent clashes on the one cent and all were only on the obv. Never found one showing on the rev. Most were of the memorial only.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1137 Posts |
I posted one the other day with a clash of lincoln's collar in one of the bays in the memorial.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1137 Posts |
I posted one the other day with a clash of lincoln's collar in one of the bays in the memorial.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1137 Posts |
I posted one the other day with a clash of lincoln's collar in one of the bays in the memorial.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
12437 Posts |
Quote: I've never heard of "ghosting", probably just an nontechnical term that someone used. Yes, "ghosting" is not quite the proper terminology but that it what the phenomenon is frequently called. More correctly, it is termed "transfer die wear" or "heavy design transfer". From Alan Herbert's The Official Price Guide to Mint Errors 7th Ed.- Quote: A die that was damaged due to repeated and lengthy use to strike coins which results in the vague outline of the central design element of the opposing die being transferred to the other die through the planchets as they are struck.
This phenomenon is quite common on Teens and 20s Lincoln Cents and is frequently confused with clashed dies.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
162 Posts |
Biokemis6, if you go to the thread where the guy asked me to go where there was "Ghosting", there wasn't anything technical about what was said. The OP and replies to that thread weren't saying it was a real ghost or phenomenon, they were pretty much saying "You're crazy, there's nothing there, you're seeing ghosts" but in a more polite way. One even said he see's ghosts all the time, but after he eats "bad burritos"... Also, the "ghosting" in that thread he linked is just the reflection whereas this isn't so I don't see why anyone would say they're similar if they're 2 completely different things. I don't know why were talking about die clashes on the reverse, they WILL happen 100% of the time due to the nature of how Clashed Dies happen. Yes, they CAN be changed, but they will ALWAYS hit both sides when the Die Clash originally happened.... The die's not going to strike itself.
I'm 100% positive this coin is a Clashed Die, there's no way that 10 things match up perfectly with other 1925-S Clashed Dies, even the rotation is perfect. All of the abrasion is in the perfect spots as well. I guess I'll have to wait for someone with more knowledge about this specific piece.
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
162 Posts |
Just to clarify this is NOT "Heavy Design Transfer" or more technically known as Die Deterioration. The key to " Die Deterioration" or "Ghosting" is the rotation of the Head that is "Ghosted" on the reverse of coins. For ghosted coins, if you look at the obverse, then look at the reverse, the "ghost" will be rotated in the same direction. Whereas with a Die Clash, if you look at the obverse then look at the reverse, the clashed images of abe is flipped 180 degrees like it should with his head under "AMERICA", not under/in the word "ONE". http://www.error-ref.com/Progressiv...ansfer_.html
|
|
Valued Member
 United States
162 Posts |
EDITED: This post is completely wrong, I now know that. I was confused and basing what a Wheat cent ghost looked like from an inaccurate thread that wasn't a ghosted coin. I'll keep this post here because I don't like deleting things that are said. -TheCentMan To further prove my point this isn't Die Deterioration I made this nice image for those of you who don't like to read. It's REALLLLLLLY easy to tell the difference between the 2. With Die Deterioration, the 2 images are lined up even in rotation whereas with Die Clashes the images are flipped 180 degrees. 
Edited by TheCentMan 11/05/2012 5:00 pm
|
| |
Replies: 25 / Views: 2,873 |