Franklin Over-Priced?

cc99999, so did the seller tell you the price was a listing error and he was going to fix it or not? I am lost with your responses you made. The first one said he said it was a typo and then the second response you made said it was about something else? was it about the price or what was it about that you contacted the seller about?

That's too bad they just flat out lied to us, giving the two different answers.

Ah, the 1959 proof Franklin.

I just got a call back from the PNG, who contacted the seller Kedzie Koins. Kedzie stands by their price as it stands saying that the coin has cameo "tendencies" which aren't visible in the scan of the coin. They say that the coin is priced fairly as 1959 cameos sell for significant amounts of money. They do not state any of this in their their item description but they do offer a 14 day money back return policy.

So there you have it. A sloppy listing. A little bit of wishful thinking based on the scan. And an inconsistent message to two different customers. Happy bidding.

So even if we say that NGC got it wrong and it is cameo its still listed for about double the numismedia listing price.