Quote:
Conder101
Posted Today 1 Hr 22 Min ago
It is not a head of 93 (S-17-20), and it is not a starred reverse (S-48). The last picture gave me the feature I needed, I'd say it it is a S-42 which is a low R-4 coin. Not rare enough to be worth a premium.
I just got a copy of the 1958 version of Penny Whimsy just today and was going to come here and edit my post to say, everything fit 42, except for the stars.
The berries are right (except my example seems to have had one worn off on the left hand side) and the obverse is right with high liberty and the thick curl of hair.
But those stars are definitely there. I wonder if someone was fooling around with the coin knowing about the star variety. Might be the same culprit who plated it.