| Author |
Replies: 10 / Views: 2,341 |
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
1751 Posts |
Over in the Canadian section we have a very active individual; who is working to combat counterfeit coins of all types. His CCF name is nickels guy or Mike Marshal. He has given talks at Torontos coin expo, and had a couple newspaper write ups. One write up in his town paper the Trenton's paper. I'd don't know how to do links sorry. Maybe someone can find the link over on the Canadian forum, I believe it's under topic coin expo. That was held at the beginning of nov. Mike is gearing up for an educational project cost $4,000. To help raise funds he is selling a disc. With almost 400 images of counterfeit coins on ebay. I thought people over here may be interested. There is links on Canadian topic counterfeit coins. Mike works with one royal canadian mounted police officer to eradicate these coins. He also knows who some of the Chinese counterfeit manufactures are. He is very instrumental in getting several counterfeit coin ads pulled from ebay. He has a Canadian ebay contact, as in the talk he gave at coin expo in Toronto, Ontario , he had an ebay Canada rep and the RCMP officer all present. I would like to hear others concerns regarding counterfeit coins? I would also like to get ideas how we can help battle this problem? Lastly nickels guy(Mike Marshall) is always looking to collect examples of counterfeits to study and add to his disk of images. If anyone has any they can donate or sell reasonably please contact nickels guy! I feel the future and credibility of our hobby is a stake!
|
|
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United Kingdom
548 Posts |
Well, I don't know if this will be much use but here is an example of a common counterfeit £1 coin that I pulled from circulation.  Just in case there's anyone wanting to collect modern British currency there are millions of these in circulation. This is obviously one of the poorer copies.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
Australia
21786 Posts |
I am VERY concerned about fake coins. However, my chief area of interest is in ancient coins, when it comes to fakes. My collection of about 100 fake ancient coins. As a spin off, I also have a collection of about 20 or so modern fake coins. Actually handling the fakes and closely examining them provides an excellent education on how to identify them.
I will collect fake coins PROVIDED THAT they are sold as fakes. If I believe that intent is made to deceive, I will go out of my way to expose the seller. I am aware however that honest mistakes are occasionally made by dealers, and I will go out of my way in a friendly manner to point out out my observations, and enter into serious and friendly discussions to prevent a re occurrence.
I was stung once, many years ago, and I did NOT like it. I vowed with good education, to be hopefully never to be caught again.
I also have some good reference books on fake coins.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
2781 Posts |
I think they a lot more prevalent than people think (or talk about). It is so easy to buy online now, and miss picking up on a fake that you might've once spotted in hand when visiting a dealers shop or coin show (like in the old days when that was the only option). It is also just as easy to buy (& reintroduce to the marketplace) anonymously online from offshore dealers who are willing to ship single coins direct from the factory. Most scary I think is the quality of the fakes... laser engraved dies & high tech presses have some looking better than legit issues. TPG'ers are also no longer a safety net. Legally there is little to no recourse (or interest) in dealing with foreign governments where a large percentage of these fakes come from, and even if someone gets caught on home soil it doesn't get treated in the same way as if someone was printing out $100 bills, when really there isn't much difference. Mike Marshall has educated a lot of people and saved a lot of heartache, a few more like him sure would make a difference.
|
|
Valued Member
United Kingdom
152 Posts |
Re Fake Copy Counterfeit Your question is not quite right Counterfeit coins or banknotes are made to be spent by a forger Copy coins are either made to sell as copies or deceive collectors Fake coins are coins that don't exist just made up I am not really concerned about conterfeit coins as I either keep them or just re spend them. ( I get around 3 or 4 a week of fake £1 coins) Liverpool England Never bought a copy coin as real (been cheated) Fake coins just dont buy them yours michael opened my 1st coin shop 1981 my web site went live 1996 listed my 1st coin on ebay.com Jan 1999
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
13014 Posts |
Quote: It is so easy to buy online now, and miss picking up on a fake that you might've once spotted in hand when visiting a dealers shop or coin show (like in the old days when that was the only option). It is also just as easy to buy (& reintroduce to the marketplace) anonymously online from offshore dealers who are willing to ship single coins direct from the factory. Theres certainly a negative aspect to that. At the same time though theres the counterbalance that theres no more free information available to collectors than ever before. While counterfits have gotten so has the ability of individuals to get other opinions and do research to detect them. For the sake of argument if the counterfeits do happen to get so good one day no one can tell they really become real until someone can figure it out. Thats kind of the sad conclusion that may happen at one point in time but in a lot of ways this reminds me of bullet proof armor and guns. The gun has to be invented before the armor can be made for it. In this case the counterfeit has to happen before we can learn to spot it. Its also going to be a back and forth battle. Overall though I do think the internet has been a positive with the massive amounts of new information that may not have been previously available to people.
|
|
Bedrock of the Community
United States
20753 Posts |
Counterfeit, fake, copies, etc. have been around as long as there is something to copy. In some situations they ruin a hobby or buesness. For example Beanie Babies, Hot wheel cars, sporting cards, etc. There are also many copies of oil paintings, furnature, cars and almost anything worth making a copy of. Very possibly many, many collectors of coins and dealers too have some and don't know it. Ever watch the Antique Road show? So many times people bring in a fake something. To some people making copies, counterfeits, fakes, etc. is the only thing they do for a living. They think of it as their job. All the rest of us can do is look, learn and hope.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 Canada
1751 Posts |
@ wade I'm wondering if you could post a link to the Toronto or Trenton interview Mike did in Nov for the coin expo. Also If you could post a link to his auction, so others can see some of the images he has collected. His story about his friend, who spent his savings on two rare coins that turned out to be counterfeit really touched me deeply. I would be in a real pickle, if the silver coins I bought could only be sold for melt, when some of them I paid $100 per Oz. . I don't think what an impact these coins will have on the hobby, especially when people stop trusting online sources to buy from. As example say, a person had to suddenly disperse some coins to cover medical expenses. Who would buy these coins when they aren't certain they are real. The coin dealers could pay even lower prices, because there's little competition from private sellers. It's even scarier in my reading that certified coins in slabs have been faked. I know it will never be completely stopped. Hey let's try to crimp their style. ebay doesn't allow the sale of copy/replica/ counterfeit coins. They will remove the auction if reported. CCF has a link for reporting under its Auctions Subheading, lets use it, it's supposed to work faster than the standard link for reporting on ebay. So here is one tool at everyone's disposal to use. It's by sharing information and keeping an open mind, we all learn. I never knew of this issue until I stumbled across a couple of Mike's post. I was in blissful ignorance. Now I've awaken to the danger and it's becoming a passion to reduce the risks for all. Whenever I find it possible to do, I'm still a newbie, so my impact may be small, but still an impact if I can get some people educated to the issue.
Edited by pocket change 50 11/18/2013 11:01 pm
|
|
Valued Member
United States
66 Posts |
Have not thought too much of it, but I was reading an article regarding metal 3-D printers just yesterday and wondered how long it would be till I could make my own.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 Canada
1751 Posts |
Here's an article I just read, it deals with a US coin dealer helping to nab someone selling thousands of dollars of counterfeit coins. The pro thief had already sold to 2 area coin shops. The article also states the US is in the process of pass a bill to protect collectors coins. I say kudos to the states government, other governments need to be as proactive. You can find this article by googling Wake County: coin dealer flips the game on counterfeiter. There is also a link on 1st Canadian subforum topic auction for counterfeit canadian or something close to it, author of post is SSP Ottawa. Sorry I have a very short memory when it comes to long titles. I have to have another page open to copy from . It is a good read.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
2781 Posts |
here is auction: ebay # 251381255967he's not trying to make money on this, just trying to cover the $4,000 in hard expenses that he is out of pocket. sorry, I do not have copies of his interviews or presentations.
|
| |
Replies: 10 / Views: 2,341 |
|