| Author |
Replies: 15 / Views: 1,940 |
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1300 Posts |
Ok I am about to buy a DSLR camera.. Have been doing lots of reading and there is just so much.. My question is with my DSLR with macro feature and manual focus all that what lens should I use? Some go as high as 200mm do I need that much? Anyways thanks this is a great section. Its just time I start posting much better photos just a overall whats the best lens for coin photography is my question. I'm leaning toward a nikon d60 and d5200
|
|
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
507 Posts |
If you don't already have a DSLR do a lot of reading of this subforum first. There is a $400 budget setup thread that is very informative. You'll see Canons recommended here for one very important reason: tethered live-view. You can control everything from your computer screen, including seeing live previews. That alone is worth a lot. It would help if you said exactly what you were interested in: variety close-ups, full face shots of Morgan dollars, etc. As for lenses I am using an el-nikkor 75mm on a bellows (thanks Ray  ) which provides full-face pictures for coins from half-dime to silver dollar size. But my best recommendation would be to spend several days reading old threads from this subforum. Feel free to ask questions. -wheatiefan
|
|
Valued Member
Australia
90 Posts |
As you have decided to go the dedicated macro lens way :- The lens will need to be 1:1 capable.Tamron 90mm (Value for money choice} Tokina 100mm Sigma 105mm Not to forget Nikons own glass which will cost more than the body you have chosen.  If you choose a Canon body the same lenses apply.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
4038 Posts |
You had me almost to the end. Then you said "Nikon" :0
That's OK, Nikons are good. Is the camera just for coins, or will you carry it around?
The longer the lens, the longer the working distance. If you go with 200mm lens, you'll need a big stand to hold it steady and far away from the coin. 150mm is more reasonable. What size coins will you mostly shoot?
If you will use the camera for multiple purposes, then a macro lens makes a lot of sense, as does Nikon. My carry-around camera is a Nikon D7000. A tripod mount is nice if you get a dedicated macro lens.
If you will use the camera only for coins, then you will probably do better with a Canon camera and alternative lenses. Look over at the "under $400" and "under $350" threads.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1300 Posts |
I would like to be able to photograph all coins including zooms on error coins. Found a nikon d60 with the 55:200mm(think I am saying that right) found the macro hood and shade. Going to buy a few filters.. My current camera just does not have the ability to manual focus or it would be perfect. Canon SX50HS I have taken some very nice cameo photos. It just doesn't have that zoom on a coin and image the ultra finne details. I am also building a copy table. It should be a good setup. I am just concerned with lens choice. I have spent about the last 18 hours reading on cameras and lenses. I am definitly not going to jump blindly on this. Its seems as though. One could definitly over spend. But I would like the camera to be universal. I'm not a take the camera everywhere kind of person. And as bad as this sounds I dont want to do entry level would like a legit system for years of enjoyment. Have gotten some great advice and read some great threads.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United Kingdom
2133 Posts |
Quote: The lens will need to be 1:1 capable. What does this mean, please ? What is the impact ? What are the alternatives ? Are there disadvantages ?
|
|
Moderator
 United States
23522 Posts |
Quote: I would like to be able to photograph all coins including zooms on error coins. That will require multiple lenses. "Normal" lenses - like that 55-200 - aren't designed for Macro work and can't focus close enough to a coin to make for good imaging. 1:1 lenses can focus closely enough so the coin fills the complete sensor. This is too much magnification for, say, a Morgan - a 38mm coin on a 22.3x14.9 sensor is about 0.42x magnification - but you'll need it for a Dime or Cent. The bare minimum magnification for useful coin imaging is about 0.5x.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
3486 Posts |
"... I dont want to do entry level would like a legit system for years of enjoyment." There is a bit of wisdom that goes: "Only a rich person can afford a bargain." No matter how painful, focus on a camera setup (or anything!) that you will not be disappointed in. It doesn't have to be the best (there is always another coming down the pike) but rather something better than the lowest.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
4038 Posts |
Any new camera you buy will be outdated in less than a year, and you may be quite upset at the amount you paid for it and the features you're now missing. It's nice to strive for the best, but at this point you probably don't know what your technique for coin photography will be or thus what is really important to you.
I said this in another post, but at this point I know only of a few cameras that are truly state of the art for coin photography, and they are all Canon models. If you're interested in doing details it is especially important to go this direction. With Nikon you can indeed get excellent images at higher magnification, but you will need to use flash, which limits your lighting flexibility. Canon's EFSC, which is fully functional only on a few models, gives vibration-free exposure with continuous lighting.
Contact me for photographic equipment or visit my home page at: http://macrocoins.com
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
589 Posts |
"I said this in another post, but at this point I know only of a few cameras that are truly state of the art for coin photography, and they are all Canon models. If you're interested in doing details it is especially important to go this direction. With Nikon you can indeed get excellent images at higher magnification, but you will need to use flash, which limits your lighting flexibility. Canon's EFSC, which is fully functional only on a few models, gives vibration-free exposure with continuous lighting." Sorry I don't mean to steal the tread but just a few questions. Any later date model of Cannon DSLR is better than buying a Nikon for coins only? Daily deal's on ebay for around $700 the Cannon T3i total package with multiple lenses would that be all I need to buy?
|
|
Moderator
 United States
23522 Posts |
Quote:Any later date model of Cannon DSLR is better than buying a Nikon for coins only? Daily deal's on ebay for around $700 the Cannon T3i total package with multiple lenses would that be all I need to buy? EFSC is Electronic First Shutter Curtain. These days, cameras snap the shutter by drawing a 2-piece curtain over the sensor, rather than the "aperture snapping open and closed" picture we typically have in mind for cameras. EFSC means that, essentially, Canon substitutes "turning the sensor on" for "pulling a curtain over a live sensor." Nikon lacks this feature, and Ray was easily able to demonstrate significant gains in sharpness with it. None of the lenses packed with a T3i are going to be appropriate for coin photography. You need something whose magnification capability is no less than 0.5x and preferably 1x, which is well beyond the ability of the average carry lens.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
589 Posts |
Thanks SuperDave. Time to start bidding on used camera.
|
|
Moderator
 United States
23522 Posts |
Quote: Time to start bidding on used camera. If you're looking at Canon, nothing older than the 450D/Rebel XSi (or 1000D/Rebel XS, our "cheap camera of choice). EFSC was implemented in that generation.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1300 Posts |
Update, have a new camera and it came with a macro Lens its a nikon and it does a great job so far.. Now to build a setup similiar to the "400 budget setup" wow I am impressed I was surprised at what I thought I knew.. Lets just say.. If it was not for the manual I would have returned it thinking it was broke!! Haha not quite as easy as the point and shoot!! The project continues!
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
4038 Posts |
OK, tell us what you bought, we won't criticize. And let's see some pictures! Taken WITH the camera/lens, not OF it.
Most likely your macro lens won't do the zooms on error coins you said you wanted, so you'll need to figure something else out. Knowing what you bought will help determine what you need to make the higher magnification shots happen...Ray
Contact me for photographic equipment or visit my home page at: http://macrocoins.com
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1300 Posts |
Edited by rupester 05/16/2014 12:41 am
|
| |
Replies: 15 / Views: 1,940 |
|