| Author |
Replies: 11 / Views: 2,075 |
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
1215 Posts |
Hey... It is common notion by many people that the price of silver is "pegged" with that of oil and there is somehow a direct causation between oil price fluctuations and silver price fluctuations. However, what I don't get is why do oil fields in Saudi Arabia have ANYTHING to do to cause production of mines in Australia, Mexico and Argentina and also demand of the metal?
I mean, you may argue that it takes substantial energy to mine silver, and you are totally right, but the same goes with other metals including aluminum, copper, zinc, nickel, iron, etc.
Plus, the silver being mined now is nothing compared to the existing supply. Additionally, there is a changing demand market which also sets price.
Mining has a supply element that is independent of how much energy you put into it: Mines can dry up, more silver fields can be discovered and silver production is just a matter of chance.
So why is silver causally related to oil?
|
|
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Australia
3831 Posts |
Just where are you hearing all these rumors?
It's true that when oil prices rise, cost of mine production goes up drastically especially when trucks burn through 4000 - 8000 liters on a daily basis.
Silver on the other hand is a byproduct of various mine production - usually gold, copper and zinc are the targeted minerals. Silver is just an extra bonus. Not common for a mine to specifically target silver - in fact I cannot think of any.
As of how silver is pegged to the price of oil - I might as well start a rumor that the price of rare earth metal is pegged to the Chinese economy.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
3692 Posts |
Metals don't follow the usual supply and demand templates that other things do. When the price goes down people wait too long to buy because they want to see it go lower and when the price starts to rise there is a frenzy to buy thinking they will buy too late. Do the opposite of what people are doing and you'll be alright.
If oil was tied with silver then Mexico would be the richest republic in the world two times over - petrol and silver are like water down there.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1215 Posts |
"Keep your eye on oil. Silver will drop with oil." That's what someone said to me today.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
4333 Posts |
All the rules have flown out the window. Everything's upside down anymore.
When I listen to LED ZEPPELIN...so do my neighbors... Roll hunting since '77 Dirt fishing since '72
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
711 Posts |
I don't have the data to prove this, but I am sure oil is correlated with silver, not a strong correlation but there should be some. What they guy meant when he said watch out for oil dropping leading to lower silver, is likely a comment on deflationary forces / demand destruction in the centrally planned global economy. If you wanted to look at the price of metals, I would check them vs the cost of oil, the dow / s&p, the US$ index, and then other precious metals. Here is a link with some interesting charts. The link is the historical GSR (gold to silver ratio). Below that chart are the ones for stocks and oil and whatnot. http://www.macrotrends.net/1441/gol...orical-chartI imagine the strongest correlation is metal to metal followed by metal to the US$ index, but inversely correlated of course.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
2661 Posts |
Quote: Metals don't follow the usual supply and demand templates that other things do. When the price goes down people wait too long to buy because they want to see it go lower and when the price starts to rise there is a frenzy to buy thinking they will buy too late. Do the opposite of what people are doing and you'll be alright. Thanks for posting that Libertad. I was scoffed at last week on here for supporting dollar cost averaging when buying PM's, especially silver. was told by some novices that I would be loosing money when the price dropped even further. But then again I am not looking for the quick profit either, so I small quantities when I can find it locally no matter which way the price is moving.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
 United States
1215 Posts |
Buy Low, Sell high!
Do the opposite of what most people are doing
|
|
Pillar of the Community
Canada
3692 Posts |
@Tim: "But then again I am not looking for the quick profit either, so I buy small quantities when I can find it locally no matter which way the price is moving."
Yeah, it's all about what you're doing with the metal, right?
^Caveat, take my words lightly. They're based on some experience but I am not the metal gospel.
The whole "dollar-cost-averaging" scheme is nice on paper, but it always reminds me of the movie The Boiler Room. Gold-to-silver ratio is good for small-time accumulators if they want metal for the sake of metal, counting in ounces not dollars.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
3789 Posts |
No such thing.... whats next, the Lego pegged to oil correlation? ?  Correlations come and go also, they do not last. Finally, all commodities are down and are in downtrends. Those who who are bringing up these ratios are simply trying to find ways to explain why gold and silver are tumbling. They wish to avoid the simple and true reason silver, gold, oil, corn, cotton and other commodities are down- supply and demand. Right now there is too much supply for the demand.... and at the end of the day, silver and gold are no different from any other commodity. Simple  Finally, for the record once again- dollar cost averaging an asset such as a commodity that is declining, is a losing proposition. doesn't matter how much you buy or your time frame, you cannot expect to buy a commodity that is declining and expect it to come back and make money on it. One of the phrases I always hear tied to this is "I have a long time frame". Well guess what, that declining asset is also going to take a longggg time before it starts doing what you wish it to do.
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
937 Posts |
Quote: No such thing.... whats next, the Lego pegged to oil correlation? ?
Correlations come and go also, they do not last.
Finally, all commodities are down and are in downtrends. Those who who are bringing up these ratios are simply trying to find ways to explain why gold and silver are tumbling. A voice of reason!! Pm values are not down because of oil being down, I mean if you look at long term trends gold and silver have been trending down for over two years. Now we have all these market geniuses telling us it is because of oil production. The bigger reason PM are down is the big money is out of it, the realy big mony got out over two years ago. Find were the big money is that is the next opertunity, but we have already missed it. Who knows maybe we should all dump PM and buy into Moon Mining. 
|
|
Pillar of the Community
United States
711 Posts |
Moon mining won't be cost effective until I tether the moon to the earth with a space elevator. Fairly low on my to do list so don't get your hopes up. . . . .
Pegged is the wrong word here, but there is some correlation for sure. I think correlation is getting a bad name here that should have been reserved solely for pegged like some foreign currency exchange rate.
Legos are most certainly correlated with the cost of oil. Probably not a strong correlation, but oil is a feedstock of plastics so there should be some correlation, likely factored down by the materials % of COGS. Natural gas is likely more correlated to plastic parts though as the ethylene feedstock of choice.
Ratios are important too. Unless the ratio of oil to gas is below the 6 to 8 range, it is more economical to crack natural gas for ethylene (and almost no propylene) vs the more expensive cracking of oil for nearly the same amount of ethylene but a bonus of some more propylene. The only reason this isn't in the exact same ratio as output of ethylene to propylene is that the cost of ethylene and propylene are determined by different demand dynamics. Sometimes the market values one molecule over the other.
Oil and gas are most certainly somewhat correlated to all plastic parts. The more the cost of the part is materials cost, the more correlated.
As such, silver is correlated to oil. Oil (derivatives) are direct input costs into mining so there must be some correlation. It is probably a fairly low correlation I would imagine though.
Now things like silver being a byproduct of other mining (much like propylene production being a byproduct of ethylene production when cracking natty gas) will lessen the correlation for sure, but it is still there.
Edited by BuckeyeCoinGuy 11/15/2014 07:18 am
|
| |
Replies: 11 / Views: 2,075 |
|