Alright, after reading this thread for more than 2 years now, I'm finally throwing my hat into the ring. I've been a "Lurker" long enough on this forum.
To date I have gone through 71 boxes of nickels, though not one has actually been in "BOX" format because no one up here has a clue what I'm talking about. So here are my findings.
Through 71 Boxes:
1938: (9), 1946: (81), 1954-S:(19)
1938-D:(2), 1946-D:(31), 1955: (2)
1938-S:(0), 1946-S:(6), 1955-D:(56)
1939: (46), 1947: (45), 1956: (22)
1939-D:(1), 1947-D:(15), 1956-D:(64)
1939-S:(2), 1947-S:(17), 1957: (23)
1940: (95), 1948: (45), 1957-D:(155)
1940-D:(10), 1948-D:(22), 1958: (14)
1940-S:(26), 1948-S:(5), 1958-D:(192)
1941: (99), 1949: (32), 1959: (18)
1941-D:(23), 1949-D:(13), 1959-D:(180)
1941-S:(19), 1949-S:(5)
1942: (13), 1950: (2)
1942-D:(3), 1950-D:(1)
1942-P:(1), 1951: (9)
1942-S:(5), 1951-D:(10)
1943-P:(13), 1951-S:(5)
1943-D:(0), 1952: (35)
1943-S:(7), 1952-D:(22)
1944-P:(10), 1952-S:(18)
1944-D:(3), 1953: (23)
1944-S:(2), 1953-D:(50)
1945-P:(6), 1953-S:(14)
1945-D:(4), 1954: (26)
1945-S:(2), 1954-D:(87)
Total Silver Found: (53)
Buffalo Nickels: (22):
Dateless (2)
1916, 1925-D , 1936 (3), 1937-D
1918-D, 1928, 1936-D,
1920, 1929 (3), 1936-S,
1923, 1935 (2), 1937 (3),
2 Headed Nickel: (1)
Proof's: (7)
2002 - S
2004 - S (Keelboat) (2)
2005-S (Bison) (2)
2005 - S (Ocean)
2006 - S
US Cents: (4)
Canadian Nickels: (512)
1949: (2), 1977: (6), 1995: (16)
1950: (2), 1978: (18), 1996: (13)
1953: (1), 1979: (14), 1997: (1)
1959: (1), 1980: (7), 1998: (25)
1960: (1), 1981: (7), 1999: (20)
1961: (2), 1982: (14), 2000: (18)
1963: (3), 1983: (17), 2001: (6)
1964: (9), 1984: (23), 2001 Plated: (1)
1965: (5), 1985: (25), 2002: (3)
1966: (2), 1986: (42), 2002 Plated: (1)
1968: (9), 1987: (17), 2003: (2)
1969: (2), 1988: (20), 2003 Plated: (1)
1971: (5), 1989: (37), 2004: (2)
1972: (1), 1990: (4), 2005: (2)
1973: (8), 1991: (1), 2005 Victory: (3)
1974: (6), 1992: (14), 2005 Plated: (2)
1975: (7), 1993: (8), 2006: (6)
1976: (4), 1994: (14), 2006 Plated: (2)
2007: (8)
2008: (7)
2009: (10)
2010: (4)
2011: (3)
5 Cent Euro's: (4)
Mexican Nuevo Peso: (1)
Mexican Peso: (2)
Mexican 50 Centavos: (2)
Bahamas Nickel: (5)
Czech Republic 2 Korun: (1)
Zimbabwe 10 Cents: (2)
Panamaa 5 Centesimos: (1)
Belgium 1 Franc: (1)
Great Britain 20 Pence: (2)
I apologize if the formatting didn't work out as planned, I tried to put them in columns, but from the preview it didn't look like it worked well.