Saleability Of My Darkly Toned 1834 50 Cent - ANACS EF 40

Toning is not the problem.
Capped Bust coins seem to come that way (I'm collecting the quarters).
ANACS will hold its value down a bit.
And as Andrew99 said it may be a touch overgraded.

Very attractive example to me!

Very pretty coin! I still cannot believe a coin series almost 200 years old, made of a hefty piece of silver, can be had for $100 or less in most cases. Beautiful coin!

I wasn't thinking retail on ebay, but what it would bring at a show. If it sells for $125 on ebay, after fees and shipping, you'd clear $100 or so. So, either way.

I was thinking high VF as well, but that originality is hard to find.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/35180514055...ig_cvip=true

Sorry to hear that. I sell full time on ebay, though what I sell has nothing to do with numismatics. I started out doing a lot of auctions. Some would do great but most would do ok and some disappointingly low. After a year of doing that I went to 100% buy it now. I put the price I want and if someone is willing to pay it they buy it. I think many of my items sell for above what they might in an auction because I only need one person to really want it, not two. Most importantly, I'm not disappointed with a sale price. Yes, I do have to lower the price a bit on some items if they sit long enough, but I feel strongly that buy it now is the way to go with anything that isn't a particularly special or unusual item. As nice as your coin is, it isn't special enough to get a bidding war.

There are a lot of people that want to buy and item and not play the auction game. They might be willing to pay, for example, $100 for an item right now instead of waiting for a week to maybe or maybe not get one for $90.