It doesn't really look like a tilted collar, more images required before it can be ID's as such.
Full Obv & Rev images would assist, but in the meantime I would agree with 2 coins being involved.
Magicians coin not very well constructed?
The top coin, eg: rev side looks like a 'dryer' coin.
If there are 2 coins involved, worth is barely $2, as these are not really sought after at all.
life is a mystery to be lived not a problem to be solved