Is This A 1909, F169 Penny

Here is my list of Penny's. I remember there being alot with letters on, looks like they are the ones that vanished?

If anyone sees something I should investigate further please tell me

I had no idea what an F169 was, so I googled "F169 penny" and the only two sites to come up were this very thread, and this page which shows the distinguishing features of this variety. It also states that less than 10 F169's have been discovered, so the chances are against you.

The severe rim wear is disappointing, as it seems to be the key diagnostic of the variety. Without it, I can't be sure either way. If the "date font looks slightly different", it could simply be because it's more heavily worn. I couldn't confidently tell the difference myself, just looking at the shapes of the numbers.

The only other thing to look at is the ocean; apparently on the F169, the "waves are more detailed". I'd suggest getting hi-res scans or pictures of the ocean section of all your 1909 coins, and putting them side-by-side. If the wave shapes are different in ways that can't be explained by wear, worn dies, etc, then you might be onto something. But I wouldn't get my hopes too high.