Real deal.
1. The edge look correct. (no saw marks)
2. The ends of the affected areas look correct. (rounded a bit, because the clip happened when it was a blank and the rounded area is caused during the strike)
3. The weakness of near the devices (as the metal feathers out at that area.)
4. Blakesley affect on the 180 degree point from the setup process that because of the clipped area did not form the proto rim on that area. (On 'AT' on STATES and near the VDB, but to the right)
Looks like a keeper.