Posted 09/01/2019 10:12 am
My opinion. These West Point mint mark quarters ungraded,raw all wind up between $10-$15 sell price so far. The newest released design does well for the first week or two and stays up above $20 for a bit longer but the best time to sell is finding the newest design as early as possible and sell it quick.
I see these all selling raw and ungraded, eventually being between $5-$10 each. Maybe a bit higher but I think as time gos on it will go lower.
Now graded. I'm seeing about $20-25 for MS64, $30-35 for MS65, $40-45 for MS66. My opinion it it isn't worth the grading unless you are pretty confident you will get at least a MS67 result back. After the fees and shipping/handling you are looking at about a $40 cost (could be cheaper if you submit more at once to spread the shipping out of course). Thinking like this, says grading hoping for a higher return when you sell isn't going to work if it results in a MS66 or below, in the short term or long term. As more get graded and sold, these prices will likely go lower.
The bright side. You found them in rolls of coins. Your cost is $0.25. If you sell them raw for $10-$15 it's good profit on a per coin basis no reason to give money to grading companies to maybe make your profit lower right?
Keep them or sell them if you need to. It's up to you. I just wouldn't spend the money on grading unless I'm sure it would come back MS67 or better. The description of a MS67 level coin is pretty clear and different enough from a MS66 that it should be clear if you evaluate it right whether or not it makes that MS67 cutoff, the way the graders would.
I really don't see the raw ungraded coins going up in value and I dont see the average grade MS65 or MS66 getting more valuable either. Grade is king, decent money is on MS67 and great money is on MS68. This could change if MS69s stsrt turning up graded though. If it qualifies I'd say give it a shot and get it graded. If it won't, due to a couple scratches or something I'd say sell them raw and don't just give money to the graders you may not he able to recover.
Even if in a year or two the raw ones go to $5.00 you are still winning because you are only $0.25 out of pocket.
I sincerely hope this helps you to figure out what you want to do. Grading could get you more money but its really grade dependant. I think it has to make sense to bother trying it. You can sell the easy for about $10 each or so on ebay. If you took them to your local coin shop, it's likely they will pay you $5 or less each.
What am I doing? I'm sitting on about 50 of them now I've got 3 candidates for MS67 or better out of them and I'm still on the fence about getting them graded. I'm not selling yet even though I feel it's likely the sell price goes down over time. In the end they cost me $0.25 each. It would be good profit if I sold them now at $10 each, but I still won't be getting rich doing it so I figure I'm just going to protect them and sit on them a while and hopefully find all 5 designs the figure out what to do from there.
I see these all selling raw and ungraded, eventually being between $5-$10 each. Maybe a bit higher but I think as time gos on it will go lower.
Now graded. I'm seeing about $20-25 for MS64, $30-35 for MS65, $40-45 for MS66. My opinion it it isn't worth the grading unless you are pretty confident you will get at least a MS67 result back. After the fees and shipping/handling you are looking at about a $40 cost (could be cheaper if you submit more at once to spread the shipping out of course). Thinking like this, says grading hoping for a higher return when you sell isn't going to work if it results in a MS66 or below, in the short term or long term. As more get graded and sold, these prices will likely go lower.
The bright side. You found them in rolls of coins. Your cost is $0.25. If you sell them raw for $10-$15 it's good profit on a per coin basis no reason to give money to grading companies to maybe make your profit lower right?
Keep them or sell them if you need to. It's up to you. I just wouldn't spend the money on grading unless I'm sure it would come back MS67 or better. The description of a MS67 level coin is pretty clear and different enough from a MS66 that it should be clear if you evaluate it right whether or not it makes that MS67 cutoff, the way the graders would.
I really don't see the raw ungraded coins going up in value and I dont see the average grade MS65 or MS66 getting more valuable either. Grade is king, decent money is on MS67 and great money is on MS68. This could change if MS69s stsrt turning up graded though. If it qualifies I'd say give it a shot and get it graded. If it won't, due to a couple scratches or something I'd say sell them raw and don't just give money to the graders you may not he able to recover.
Even if in a year or two the raw ones go to $5.00 you are still winning because you are only $0.25 out of pocket.
I sincerely hope this helps you to figure out what you want to do. Grading could get you more money but its really grade dependant. I think it has to make sense to bother trying it. You can sell the easy for about $10 each or so on ebay. If you took them to your local coin shop, it's likely they will pay you $5 or less each.
What am I doing? I'm sitting on about 50 of them now I've got 3 candidates for MS67 or better out of them and I'm still on the fence about getting them graded. I'm not selling yet even though I feel it's likely the sell price goes down over time. In the end they cost me $0.25 each. It would be good profit if I sold them now at $10 each, but I still won't be getting rich doing it so I figure I'm just going to protect them and sit on them a while and hopefully find all 5 designs the figure out what to do from there.
Edited by Big-Kingdom
09/01/2019 10:19 am
09/01/2019 10:19 am
