The 1800 is S-196, the most common of the 1800 overdate, the 1801 is S-224 also a VERY common variety. As to why someone would punch or carve the 1801, because they can/want to. How many people mutilate current coins today? Read the error coin sections on any coin forum and you will find that Post Strike Damaged/mutilated coins exceed the actual error coins shown by something like 4 to 1.


















