Help With Identification Of A Set Of 3 Coins - Coin 1

Indeed, this is a medieval gold florin. As you have found out, they were minted in Florence Italy, starting in the 13th century, but also in other pars of Europe. As best I can tell, the closest places to Andorra that minted a florin which might have historical significance to Andorra are Barcelona, and Orange, France (quite a bit farther).

It could be authentic and clipped (which would fit the weight), or could be a replica. Because so much of the legend is missing, it might be hard to know.

If you know a jeweller who could test if it is gold, that would be helpful.

Edit: Looking more closely, I think I see a well-defined rim around part of the coin, which is more suggestive of a replica. The color also doesn't look right (even old gold normally looks ...gold), but that can be an artifact of the photo conditions.

sorry for the lesser quality picture, it's not easy to take a good one from the edge. But if it is not enough I'll try with the better camera

to the Community!

In my opinion, this one is meant to be a florin of King Pedro of Aragon (1336-87), Valencia mint.
https://en.numista.com/catalogue/pieces124286.html
(in any event, the thread can be moved to the Ancients and Medieval forum with the other two since these florins were not minted after the 16th century)

While much of the lettering on both sides is missing, we can see the small tower mintmark to the left of St. John's halo. As best I can tell, it was only used during this reign, though maybe someone with a more extensive catalog can confirm that. Other mintmarks used on these flroins were a rosette for Barcelona, letter m for Mallorca, a helmet for Perpignan, and a crown for later reigns for Valencia. As this mark does not appear to be any of those, we come to Pedro's reign and Valencia by process of elimination, even though we can't read the legends (on the lily side we should have + ARAG from 2:00-5:00, then O REX P from 7:00-11:00).

A test of gold content will confirm if it is a replica like the other two. or might be authentic. The lettering (especially on the lily side) seems to me to be more crude than what was actually made at the time, based on the Numista photos and others which can be found with an internet search.