Quote:
Interesting how you all see 6-7 points worth of deductions on a lustrous coin free of any major hits or distractions.
thats the problem here. its not free of distractions. the photos show ticks and marks on the jaw and up and down the entire length of the lapel and a few on the shoulder. above CENT. there looks like some field discoloration in front of the profile and vertically through LIBERTY and on the reverse vertically through the A in America. this could be from lighting but we can only judge on what we see. add to this the weak obv strike
its not a clean enough coin to go much higher. the only two options here realistically using your photos is MS64 maybe a +